How do you tell Boomers "this time is different"?

One of the most significant hurdles to developing a coherent national AI policy—and especially one that takes seriously the dignity of American workers—is also one of the most fundamental: age. Simply put, many of those tasked with making crucial decisions about the development and rollout of this new technology are now in the twilight of their lives and careers. Faced with unprecedented technological circumstances, most possess few clear analogues or reference points and have only limited insights into the pace of AI development.

All proposals for national AI policy must account for this reality. It will not do to marshal immense amounts of jargon regarding “harnesses,” “Moltbook,” and “p(doom).” The political debate must be framed in straightforward, nonobscurantist terms that make the stakes clear and that—as far as possible—deploy recognizable legal and policy categories.

To be sure, the technological gap between D.C. and Silicon Valley is nothing new. For decades, government information technology systems have fallen woefully short of the cutting edge. At an agency where I previously served, laptops were in such short supply that I couldn’t even switch out one with a broken webcam, and career attorneys regularly complained that the systems were too underpowered to run modern document-review software. And when I clerked on a federal court of appeals, the judges all still used the decades-old Lotus Notes email platform, refusing to transition to Microsoft Outlook out of sheer disinterest in learning a whole new package. In the end, a stark fact remains: These are the leaders who will be making critical decisions about how law and policy respond to an immensely disruptive new technology.

Against the backdrop of such significant potential changes, old and much-cherished assumptions may no longer hold. When confronted with technologically mediated economic disruption, free-market defenders have fallen back for decades on a standard refrain: This is creative destruction that will enhance productivity in the long run. Some jobs will be destroyed; new jobs will be created. Something like this remains the reigning orthodoxy of many generations of conservative policymakers and intellectuals.

And yet this is precisely the premise that AI—if its evangelists’ prophecies prove accurate—stands to disrupt. What happens in a political moment in which greater and greater swaths of human capital are rendered almost entirely “superfluous”? Is it truly realistic to imagine junior accountants reskilling for careers in plumbing or elder care? It’s far more likely that such workers will gravitate toward radical politics, focused on redistribution rather than on good work.

If this is the world we are entering, then it will almost certainly not suffice—at least politically—to simply preach the virtues of adaptivity and sing the praises of market processes. Nor does an appeal to supposedly uncontrollable market processes reflect reality. In an environment where AI policy has often been driven by national defense considerations, it makes little sense to draw sharp lines between public- and private-sector interests. American citizens—not just American consumers—have a real stake in where this technology goes.

Those concerned to shape this future now have a clear responsibility before them. They must make an argument to battle-hardened political leaders, many of whom are in the final years of their careers, that this time really may be different—that this technological development may not be analogous to the railroad, the telephone, or even the internet, but stands to potentially reconfigure far more of economic life. Old market axioms may no longer hold true, but that doesn’t mean the values those axioms embed—such as the importance of liberty, creativity, and meaningful work—are somehow now outmoded.

Over and beyond the case for any particular regulatory scheme or liability regime, making that case to a political class, voting bloc, and donor base whose imaginations were shaped before the fall of the Berlin Wall is the real battle that lies ahead.

John Ehrett
John Ehrett is an attorney and writer in Washington, D.C.
@johnehrett