Everyone wants to defend the "dignity" of work—so what is it?

The power of humanlike AI brings with it the question of what boundaries we must set on AI if we want to prevent it from dehumanizing us. To avoid dehumanization, we need some standard of flourishing humanity as our ideal and goal. The concept of human dignity often stands in as shorthand here. It has a lineage in Western civilization that is both religious and classical; a range of traditions can agree that dignity is vital without exactly agreeing as to why. There is a social and political value in finding common ground without contesting its precise status, however philosophically inconclusive.

Drawing from my Roman Catholic tradition, I offer a fourfold distinction to help understand the difference between four types of human dignity:

First, ontological dignity is the inherent, inalienable, immeasurable value of each human being. The Abrahamic religions ground this in the belief that we are created in the image and likeness of God (Genesis 1:26–27), with Christians emphasizing that we are made in love by Love for infinite, eternal love. Secular humanists and others can simply take as a foundational and self-evident truth, as does the U.N.’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights, that “all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.” (The declaration was adopted in 1948, as a response to the horrors of the world wars and especially the Holocaust, which made clear in practice what can follow from denying the principle.)

Second, moral dignity is the exercise of human freedom in a manner that flows from, respects, and reveals human dignity. Vicious persons abandon their moral dignity.

Third, existential dignity is the felt perception or self-consciousness of human dignity. Persons in despair or severe depression have lost their existential dignity.

Fourth, social dignity is the attainment of the determinants of human flourishing that promote the recognition of human dignity. Impoverished, neglected, and abused persons have been denied social dignity.

These distinctions allow one to affirm the intuition that there is something about human dignity that can never be lost, even when people act in undignified ways or live in undignified conditions.

As we consider the “bull” and “bear” scenarios concerning how AI will impact companionship, work, education, and privacy, it helps to keep the various types of dignity in mind. Does offering chatbot companions to the lonely provide social dignity while risking existential dignity? Could AI therapists promote moral and existential dignity? Does the moral dignity of a job well done matter more or less than the social dignity that might follow from distributions of material wealth produced by AI-powered robots? Is ontological dignity denied by algorithmic surveillance and sorting, even if habituation to it means that no harm is done to existential dignity? Are all four forms of dignity compromised by a relentlessly optimizing market economy that seeks only the greatest output for the fewest dollars?

As AI becomes further woven into the fabric of our society, these are the kinds of questions we need to be asking, lest we assume by default that there is in fact nothing that compute can’t buy.

Brian Boyd
Brian J. A. Boyd is the U.S. Faith Liaison for The Future of Life Institute.